An intriguing tale of isolation and desperation that promises much, but ultimately leaves it’s audience adrift.

Trapped aboard an ice-bound whaling ship, with scurvy slowly claiming the lives of its crew, Dogstar presents a fascinating premise. Here are three men confined together in the most desperate of circumstances, facing not only the certainty of death but the psychological consequences of prolonged isolation. It is fertile ground for a powerful and disturbing piece of theatre. Unfortunately, despite some fine performances, this new play by Daisy Hall never quite delivers on that promise.

There is something undeniably intriguing about watching these men struggle with their predicament. Their confinement should provide increasingly claustrophobic atmosphere, where fear, desperation and gradual disintegration of relationships become almost unbearable. Instead, much of the action descends into endless bickering, with arguments that seem to circle rather than develop. What should feel like a steadily tightening noose of tension becomes a succession of confrontations that rarely take us anywhere new.

The set too, does little to reinforce their dreadful circumstances being functional rather than atmospheric, it seems remarkably clean for a vessel supposedly imprisoned in ice. A harsher more distressed environment might have gone some way towards creating the oppressive atmosphere the play craves.

The performances are certainly committed, but the actors Justin Edwards, Abdul Jalloh, and Adam Rojko Vega are given surprisingly little opportunity to develop their characters beyond the confines of their immediate frustrations. We learn too little about the men beneath the arguments, their fears, their regrets, or what makes their individual struggles worth investing in. Consequently, their inevitable fate becomes something we observe rather than emotionally engage with.
And so, as the play reaches its conclusion, the audience is left asking perhaps the most important question about any play. What was it really trying to say?


Photo credit: Pamela Raith


LATEST REVIEWS